Landmark ruling on lease renewals could shift landlord-tenant balance of power

Supreme Court

Imminent ruling could challenge landlords’ right to refuse to renew tenants’ leases when planning major redevelopments.

In Franses vs The Cavendish Hotel, the tenant, an antique rug shop, is accusing the landlord, the hotel, of misinterpreting and misusing the Landlord and Tenant Act 1954 for the sole purpose of kicking them out.

The case specifically revolves around section 30 (1)(f) of the act. It states that a landlord can refuse a tenant’s new lease if they intend on reconstruction or demolition works that they “could not reasonably do so without obtaining possession of the holding”.

This is premium content

You must be logged in to view premium stories.

Gated access promo

Subscribe for full access

Take out a print and online or online only subscription and you will get immediate access to:

  • Breaking industry news as it happens
  • Expert analysis and comment from industry leaders
  • Unlimited access to all stories, including premium content
  • Full access to all our online archive

To get access to premium content subscribe today

Alternatively REGISTER for a free trial to access up to 4 articles and sign up for email alerts

If you are already a registered user or a subscriber you can SIGN IN now